Notable Books
I have tried to take time this year to review the book reviews. I get masses of news articles and emails showing me what the next big bestseller is going to be. I read the New York Times book reviews, The Chicago Tribune reviews and anything in the other news media about books. Publisher's Weekly does intense reviews and articles on authors and books every week from publishers and reviewers. Yet, I still cannot discern a good book from a bad book.
Maybe their are no bad books. Someone at the publisher thought it was good enough to print. Depending on how many people like it, depends on how far up the best seller list it goes.
I have seen some of the notable lists for 2008 that have come out this week. I can't understand them. These are not bestsellers or hot titles. Many of the titles, I haven't even heard of yet. It's almost like a self fulling prophecy that if you develop enough hype around a title, people will flock to it out of curiosity.
Two examples come to mind. The Tale of Edgar Sawtelle by David Wroblewski. This tome of a first novel rambles up literacy scales and down into tedium, but it is attracting huge audiences. The publisher made sure that advance reading copies hit most of the bookstores prior to publication and there have been glitzy ads in all the right places as well as notable reviewers making long winded explorations into what the author was trying to achieve with this first story that took him 10 years to write. While most reviews begin with a sparkling note, they usually end with a disclaimer that, well maybe it's not so hot after all. Most people, like me, scan these tributes with a quick eye, seeing the first few paragraphs, noting the glowing reports. We file the information and move on.
The second title was picked by our Mystery book club based on one of these marvelous reviews. In The Woods by Tana Woods is a British who dun it with plenty of twists and turns. The writing is a testimony to a great writing instructor and a good book of synonym's. Now here comes the but. It is so weighted down with adjectives and superlatives you can't find the story. And on top of it all, the initial set up plot in the Prolog is never told. You wade through it all to never solve the mystery. Perhaps, that's the goal in this "literary" mystery, but for the avid mystery readers, it doesn't work.
Maybe that's the point. I read for entertainment and fun. I love to cuddle down with a Nelson DeMille thriller or Michael McGarity mystery. These are straight forward mysteries without the introspection into the authors motive or literary value of the work.
To Each Their Own.





